Personal identity stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Essays for barry stroud edited by jason bridges, niko kolodny, and waihung wong new york. First, there is the reductive theory set out in the main body of the treatise, and. Jul 27, 2008 ok, hume is often a toughy, but i will give you a little peek into his views on personal identity he somewhat argues that personal identity, as we commonly use the term, as it relates to ordinary people, does not exist. A question of humes theory of personal identity the oxford. Hume s account is also explained by reference to earlier theories such as those. Consciousness, self, and personal identity u2 writing assignment maggie mccoy what identifies a. But it is easy to see that they are different things, and the philosophical problem of personal identity is in fact concerned with only one of them particular identity. For my part, when i enter most intimately into what i call myself, i always stumble on some particular perception or other, of heat or cold, light or shade, love or hatred, pain or pleasure. Summary david hume of personal identity flashcards. Treatise of human nature, book 1 early modern texts.
Concerning theories of personal identity patrick bailey abstract the purpose of this thesis is to provide a brief examination of the historical accounts of philosophical theories of personal identity and show the influence that each has had on the development of contemporary theories. Defending hume s theory of personal identity and discarding the appendix. At the opening of the treatise, ideas and impressions are distinguished by their degrees of vivacity. David hume of personal identity flashcards quizlet. This is his only extended discussion of the self, and his other explicit references to it are quite few in number. First, there is the reductive theory set out in the main body of the treatise, and then in the appendix there is the recantation of that theory. The full text of this article hosted at is unavailable due to technical difficulties. But, there is a flaw in his argument with the brave officer paradox. David hume, of personal identity from a treatise of human. Oct 03, 2006 hume thought that this tendency goes a long way towards explaining mistaken views about personal identity. Of personal identity by david hume this text is in the public domain and may be freely reproduced. Hume delivers his account of personal identity in treatise 1. Rethinking hume s second thoughts about personal identity don garrett new york university in the appendix to a treatise of human nature, david hume.
His philosophy was that we as humans could only perceive, or imagine a concept of self based on various thoughts and images that we could see at any given time. The strongest statement of this view is to be found in terence penelhums hume on personal identity. Memory is essential to personal identity, as it is memory which allows us the impression of a continuity of perceptions, and so in turn, the idea of cause and effect. In the appendix to a treatise of human nature, david hume wrote. Hume, buddhism, and personal identity the problem of personal identity is often said to be one of accounting for what it is that gives persons their identity over time. This paper considers hume s account of personal identity in his treatise of human nature. David humes view on personal identity ask a philosopher. Of the sceptical and other systems of philosophy section vi. Introduction the problems of personal identity the persistence question the population question the personalontology question the question of what matters in identity the persistence question. This allowed illustration the selfevaluation and monitoring of personal health in order to emphasise the way the participants construct their personal health identity through the plot of the account. The objects of the mind vary along a single dimension of force and vivacity. In david humes of personal identity, he makes his argument that the idea of existence is falsified. This being premised, to find wherein personal identity consists, we must consider what.
Locke argues both that person is a forensic term and that personal identity consists in sameness of consciousness i argue that the best way to reconcile these two claims is to interpret locke as giving a. Since locke ends up relating personal identity to consciousness and to memory, it is possible to say that, if understanding is not repeatedly presented with the idea of self identity, it would lose this idea. Hume considered the idea of identity to be both fictitious and perception based hume, 1739. This remarkable fact holds my attention for a moment. Katherine falconer hume realized that david was uncommonly precocious. Hume s positive theory of personal identity bradley m. This is a posthumous edition from humes unpublished manuscript, and contains his most detailed attack on natural religion.
It will analyse the question of whether or not hume s account is plausible, whilst using the alternative approaches to present and support the essays central thesis. From this formation of belief in general, we arrive at belief in. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Hume believes that the self is an illusion or a fiction. A question of humes theory of personal identity the. A critical study of buddhist in uence in david humes treatise of. A treatise of human nature, by david hume project gutenberg. This textbased pdf or ebook was created from the html version of this book and is part of the portable library of liberty. In the appendix to a treatise of human nature, david hume. Locke argues both that person is a forensic term and that personal identity consists in sameness of consciousness i argue that the best way to reconcile these two claims is to interpret locke as giving a moral account of personhood which. But self or person is not any one impression, but that to which our several impressions and ideas are supposed to have a.
Hume thought that this tendency goes a long way towards explaining mistaken views about personal identity. Humes positive theory of personal identity bradley m. This contains my own life and letter from adam smith, ll. Penelhum university of calgary most discussions of hume s views on the self are, naturally enough, attempts to evaluate the section of the treatise entitled of personal identity.
Jul 12, 2014 the most significant features of hume s work, as understood by reid, are the representive theory of perception, the nature of causation and causal concepts, the nature of personal identity and the. Personal identity is a concept within philosophy that has persisted throughout its history. David hume believed that while people may have notions of some unchanging personal characteristics embedded within themselves, people have actually mistaken their perceptions of themselves as the genuine article. David hume, of personal identity from a treatise of human nature, 1739 there are some philosophers, who imagine we are every moment intimately conscious of what we call our self. Both the articles on personal identity by john locke and there is no personal identity by david hume illustrate the various opinions that have been expressed through history regarding how humans define themselves and how human beings as a whole group create and individuate identity. Yet it is striking that hume does not emphasize lockes distinction between persons and human beings. Learn exactly what happened in this chapter, scene, or section of david hume 17111776 and what it means. Personal identity deals with philosophical questions that arise about ourselves by virtue of our being people or, as lawyers and philosophers like to say, persons. Twill be incumbent on those, who affirm that memory produces entirely our personal identity, to give a reason why we can thus extend our identity beyond our memory. Hume s account of person al identity by david pears hume s account of personal identity is superior to most other accounts because it is more penetrating. I shall further suggest that such an interpretation. A summary of a treatise of human nature in s david hume 17111776. He must show how these two types of association combine in. Not for quotation or reproduction without permission.
Introduction the problems of personal identity the persistence question the population question the personal ontology question the question of what matters in identity the persistence question. Paragraph numbering was not included in the original text and has been added for ease of reference. Humes theory of the self and its identity dialogue. Hume and the belief in personal identity oxford scholarship. Hume s discussion of personal identity is primarily built on the role of the imagination, which it plays in the formation of belief in general. He comes to the idea that selfbeing can not exist because since the emotions that create this selfexistence contradict itself when it is in the process. This onepage guide includes a plot summary and brief analysis of a treatise of human nature by david hume.
These two pieces of information are connected with one another, and in nigel denniss novel cards of identity the victims are deprived of both at once. In this paper, i will demonstrate that hume presents a positive and constructive view of the self in his discussion of the. I propose to examine the recently revived claim1 that it is and to argue that it rests on a superficial reading of hume s remarks on personal identity in the treatise. David hume dedicated a portion of his philosophy in the attempts to finally put what he saw as a fallacious claim concerning the soul to rest. Rethinking humes second thoughts about personal identity. This chapter begins with a close analysis of the relevant sections in book i of the treatise of human nature and hume s famous second thoughts on identity in the appendix to book iii. Dialogue on personal identity and immortality by john perry i assign john perrys dialogue on personal identity and immortality for a lively, accessible introduction to arguments for and against the three candidates for. Essentially, hume argues that the type of identity that exists in the example of the oak tree is the same type of identity in personal identity p. But though consciousness of what is past does thus ascertain our personal identity to ourselves, yet, to say that it makes personal identity, or is necessary to our being the same persons, is to say, that a person has not existed a single moment, nor done one action, but what he can remember. Since his contribution to the field of personal identity in 1738 hume s theory has been debated thoroughly. When my perceptions are removd for any time, as by sound sleep. Hume begins his discussion of personal identity by, strikingly, denying that we have any idea of the self.
In the previous section, he has rejected the ancient philosophys posit of a mental substance, or soul, in which the perceptions of the mind are said to inhere, and has argued that, in fact, each perception fits the definition of substance as something which may exist by itself. Interview with locke and hume assume you have the opportunity to interview locke and hume on personal identity. In conclusion hume s view on personal identity is in keeping with his sceptical approach, although he ultimately realizes he has in fact gone further than this strict approach allows, and that indeed he must do so. Supersummary, a modern alternative to sparknotes and cliffsnotes, offers highquality study guides that feature detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, quotes, and essay topics. Porath citrus college one of the most vexed topics in hume scholarship is his position regarding personal identity. Nov 02, 2015 hume s theory of personal identity is developed in response to lockes account of personal identity. I know that john locke states that personal identity is based off memory, for example, prince and cobbler. Humes account of person al identity by david pears humes account of personal identity is superior to most other accounts because it is more penetrating. David hume and the theatre metaphor alessandra stradella introduction i should like to begin this essay of mine on man by some fables and plays, since man is himself a fable and a play. Hume and personal identity free download as word doc. Locke but once memory has done its work, then our personal identity can be extended even to times forgotten.
Of personal identity david hume there are some philosophers who imagine we are every moment intimately conscious of what we call our self. Hume states that there is no criterion for personal identity, but i dont exactly understand his evidence or how he. To understand what personal identity consists in, we must understand what the word person designates. David hume on personal identity 2016\3\6 david hume on. Based on previous thinkers such as john locke, the scottish philosopher david hume developed his own theory of personal identity, one that is along the lines of the buddhist conception. It seems even more striking that hume s account of self in books 2 and 3 of the treatise has less scope for distinguishing persons from human. David hume personal identity essay do not hesitate, place an order and let qualified professionals do all the work. This contrasts with questions about ourselves that arise by virtue of our being living things, conscious beings, material objects, or the like. If we have the idea of gold and the idea of a mountain, we can combine them to. Hume and personal identity philosophy of self david hume. Time management is the key to success, and essay help firmly believes in this principle. David hume s philosophy on personal identity and bundle theory. David hume, a treatise of human nature by david hume.
There are no persons that continue to exist over time. Locke and hume on personal identity locke and hume both discuss the idea of personal identity in connection with certain general claims about the very idea of identity in a more general sense and i am going to begin, prior to discussing personal identity in particular, with a comparison of their specific treatments of the general idea of identity. Mattey book 1 of the understanding part 4 of the sceptical and other systems of philosophy. Hume from phil 1001 at georgia southwestern state university. A critique of humes account of personal identity hubpages. He considers memories to take over an essential part in creating personal identity, but avoids the problem of forgetfulness in declaring causality to be the connection allowing us to extend identity beyond memory. Ok, hume is often a toughy, but i will give you a little peek into his views on personal identity he somewhat argues that personal identity, as we commonly use the term, as it relates to ordinary people, does not exist. Apr 06, 2016 hume believes that the self is an illusion or a fiction. In this paper, i argue for an interpretation of the passage in humes treatise where he talks about the fiction called personal identity. It is noticeworthy that hume neglects any possibility of solving the problem of personal identity by considering attributions of identity. This idea can be formulated as the following argument. However, once the problem has been construed in these terms, it is plain that too much has already been assumed.
Locke en hume als voordenkers van postmoderne persoonlijke. The identity which we ascribe to the mind of man is only a fictitious one 168. Start studying summary david hume of personal identity. Mar 25, 2018 david hume s philosophy on personal identity and bundle theory. Pdf hume on personal identity nicko miranda academia. They may signal a populating of the self, the acquisition of multiple and. Dan robinson gives the fifth of eight lectures on thomas reids critique of david hume at oxford. One of the problems with this discussion, that penelhum also remarks upon hume on personal identity, pp. What man who has not met with personal provocation or what goodnatured man who has could inflict on crimes, from the sense of blame alone, even the common, legal, frivolous punishments.
David hume, of personal identity trosiethoughts blog posts november 7, 2018 november 19, 2018 2 minutes prompt. The concept of the self in david hume and the buddha. In this view, therefore, memory does not so much produce as discover personal identity, by shewing us the relation of cause and effect among our different perceptions. The perception of self is a subjective interpretation of reality and is necessarily colored by the subjects own preconceived notions. Other essays in the text which focus on conceptions of the. David hume, of personal identity from a treatise of. Excellent assignment help online is right around the corner. Whence do we learn that there is such a thing as moral distinctions, but from our own sentiments. Hume agrees with lockes premise, but not his conclusion locke assumes existence of the self to prove its existence hume doesnt allow that it must be some one impression that gives rise to every real idea. Appearing in the possibility of philosophical understanding. The personal and social nature of identity gives the construct its greatest theoretical potentialnamely to provide insight into the relationship between the individual and society.
When david hume published his literary debut a treatise of human nature in. Paragraph numbering was not included in the original text and has been added for ease of. Personal identity in memento plato philosophy learning. Humes second answer is related to his above account of identity and relation. This work will particularly deal with the latter theory initiated by english philosopher david hume. In the eighteenth century this problem came to a head. Oct 16, 2009 but what we ought to say is that a relation exists, not an identity. There are some philosophers, who imagine we are every.
Even today, argument rages as to what hume s view on personal identity. Perfect for acing essays, tests, and quizzes, as well as for writing lesson plans. Biro as hume s theory of the self a logicalconstruction theory. Hume s theory of the self and its identity it is a widely held view among philosophers that hume s doctrine of personal identity is seriously mistaken, that he makes claims about the existence and nature of personal identity that are clearly. Hume david hume 17111776 is one of the british empiricists of the early modern. Philosophy through film, routledge, 2002 by mary litch for further reading on personal identity in memento. The section concerning personal identity to which humes.
Dec 08, 2011 in his of personal identity, 1 david hume criticizes the idea of personal identity. It is a widely held view among philosophers that hume s doctrine of personal identity is seriously mistaken, that he makes claims about the existence and nature of personal identity that are clearly false. Similar to the other presented theories, humes account on personal identity is subject to criticism. Throughout the years there have been multiple critiques of hume s theory, but despite the fact that all. I never can catch myself at any time without a perception, and never can observe any thing but the perception. Of personal identity david hume there are some philosophers who. For, he thought, when we encounter several different things existing in succession and differing gradually, one from the next, this resemblance is the cause of the confusion and mistake, and makes us substitute the notion of identity.
944 14 196 494 401 1384 1284 1597 591 1060 1432 239 876 322 542 1395 649 1241 735 837 130 838 1270 739 1418 718 1160 721 662 175 673